|
Ask the Experts: Questions of the Week
5/15/08
Question: "I am just a 48 year old club player who usually ..."
5/15/08
Name: Bernardo
Current Blade: Timo Boll Spirit
Current Forehand: Butterfly Cermet
Current Backhand: Butterfly Cermet
Question: "Hi, I was thinking to purchase the new Sriver High Tune, because I don't want to reglue anymore, but what happens if I don't feel the power and spin on the rubber anymore. Can I use the Speed Optimizer One to increase the speed and power of my rubber?, or What do you recomend to not lose the efect of the rubber?. Thank You"
Answer: Hello Bernardo,
Sriver High Tune keeps it’s built in glue effect for quite a while. However, if you feel like it is slowing down as it ages; you can certainly use our Speed Optimizer to restore the glue effect.
Best wishes,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member
|
Name: Roberto
Current Blade: Sardius
Current Forehand: Raystorm
Current Backhand: C8 Long
Question: "I am just a 48 year old club player who usually beats younger players due to my close to the table defense & attack style, my question is, what is the best long pimples-out rubber that i can use for my backhand defense & attack and best short pimples-out rubber for my forehand defense & attack? I'm quite contented with my powerful sardius.
I'm hoping to give younger players more trouble by following your suggestions. Thanks & More Power Smashes"
Answer: Hello Roberto,
It would be hard to give you a good answer regarding long pips with out knowing much more about your style of play. C8 Long pips are a popular choice, especially the no sponge model. However, if you are looking for a more offensive long pips, you may want to try our new Feint AG.
Your Raystorm pips produces the most spin of any of our short pips rubbers but because of this, its returns will seem very normal to your opponents. If you play your forehand with more spin than with a flat hit, then this is the perfect rubber for you. If you want a little less spin, a lower trajectory return, and more control try our Challenger Attack Rubber. If you want more speed, and a more difficult ball for your opponent to handle, try Speedy PO or Flarestorm. Finally, our Relop pips rubber has a little longer pips, almost medium long in length. If will produce a wide variety of returns that will cause your opponent’s the most problems dealing with.
Best wishes,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
Name: May
Current Blade: Keyshot Light
Current Forehand: Sriver FX
Current Backhand: Sriver FX
Question: "Hello,
I had this problem for a few months now. I really want faster rubber on my forehand, but spinnier rubber on my backhand. What should I switch to on my forehand and backhand?
Thanks"
Answer: Hi May,
I personally used Sriver FX for many years and recommend it to many of my students. Here are some options. Sriver FX is great for speed gluing so you can use what you already have on your forehand. If you want more spin but don’t want to lose the control on your backhand, try Tackifire or Tackifire Soft (Without speed gluing). But if you are more confident and experienced and want both more spin and speed, consider Bryce FX or Sriver G2FX for backhand and forehand speed glued.
Masaaki Tajima |
Name: Rob
Question: "I am an aggressive topspin slam kinda guy on both forehand and backhand. I want maximum speed with as much spin as possible. I do NOT want to reglue. I have narrowed my rubber choices down to Bryce Speed or Bryce High Tune. High Tune is much more expensive, and yet has lower speed and spin numbers. Why is that? Are the Bryce Speed speed and spin numbers dependent on reglueing? Which rubber would you recommend for me?"
Answer: Hello Rob,
The pricing of various types of rubber or blades is based on production costs and does not indicate one is a better quality product than another. For example, far more tournament players use Sriver rubber which is much less expensive than either Bryce Speed or Bryce High Tune. The technology used to produce the permanent fresh glue feeling of our High Tune rubbers is very expensive and thus the high cost of these products. Bryce Speed is faster than Bryce Tuned. Be aware that rubber this fast requires lots of training time to achieve good control.
Best wishes,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach + Hall of Fame Member |
Name: Erwin
Current Blade: Gergely
Current Forehand: Joola Air Rosnet
Current Backhand: Butterfly Sriver EL
Question: "Once, on my very first international tourney, I've encountered a Chinese with a serve that from his side of the table the ball seemingly going to my backhand but upon bouncing unto my side of the table it suddenly swerve going to my forehand. I am just wondering what serve it is? Is it the cork screw serve? and how it is being executed? Please."
Answer: Erwin,
This is a difficult question without being able to see the serve you are asking about. Back in the days of the hidden serves (around 5-6 years ago you could hide contact with your arm and body) this result would happen more often because players would wiggle their wrists super fast and move almost simultaneously in both directions as they grazed the ball. This made the results you describe because it MIGHT look like they made contact in one direction ... but REALLY it was the opposite way causing you to be surprised by the bounce.
My next thought would be to search on the internet for videos of serving techniques especially using Youtube.
Also, the Chinese grip was famous for fast wristy motion and why all others copied their grips for serving by using their index finger and thumb instead.
Sincerely, Mark Nordby |
Name: Chalermsak
Current Blade: Gergely 21
Current Forehand: Bryce FX
Current Backhand: Bryce
Question: "I'm looking for the faster and softer blade than my current one, Gergely 21. Also, I'm a player who play top-spin close to the table and a little bit back-spin, so any suggestion for the rubber I should use?"
Answer: Yes, Gergely blade is very fast but not very soft. Consider Viscaria or Kumpuru blades; Viscaria is faster than Kumpuru, both are Arylate/Carbon blades with soft feel.
I am surprised you use Bryce FX on forehand and Bryce, which is faster, on backhand, especially when you like to use backspins also; I am assuming that you use backspins on your backhand and all topspin on forehand because this is the norm for some offensive oriented players. For this style of players, usually players select slower, spinier control rubber on the backhand for pushing, chopping, blocking and sometimes attacking, and hitting or variation of topspins on the forehand.
I suggest you stay with Bryce or Bryce FX on the forehand and Tackiness or Tackifire series on your backhand.
Masaaki Tajima |
Name: Mitch
Question: "I am laid back and just want to find a table that me and my friends can play in the living room every day or so. And that I can even play by myself sometimes. What is a good table for me? I was looking at the
Personal Rollaway and that one looked pretty good for me. What do you suggest?"
Answer: Hello Mitch,
All Butterfly tables are made to the highest standards in Germany. My own experience with the Personal Rollaway is that it offers an excellent bounce which is comparable to tables costing much more. For home use, I don’t think you can beat the value.
Best wishes,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
Name: Flint
Current Blade: Grubba Pro
Current Forehand: Tackifire C
Current Backhand: Tackifire C
Question: "I've been playing with this combo for a while now, I am forehand dominant and I was thinking of trying out Super-Anti for the reverse side to change the pace up at random times. My question is about the difference between Super-Anti and the Super-Anti Special. I read the descriptions for both but I have never used one before so I am in still in the dark. Thank you for your time."
Answer: Hello Flint,
The difference between the 2 antispins is the speed.The super anti special is much slower than the super anti. The super anti has a white sponge that is fast. The super anti special has a yellow sponge and is 40 percent slower.
Dan Seemiller |
Name: Eugene
Current Blade: Avalox Penhold
Current Forehand: Stiga Mendo
Current Backhand: Friendship
Question: "I'm a quick attacking, short pips competitive player (inter-versity), and I am considering a more powerful penhold blade to get more power behind my smashes. I'm relative good in controlling shots, however, it is difficult for me to get enough power behind those smashes.
I am looking at more powerful penhold blades from Butterfly (many of my friends recommend Butterfly). But may I know, which penhold blades under the Butterfly brand is the most suitable for short-pips close to table attacking style?
Best Regards."
Answer: Hello Eugene,
I am assuming that you are looking for a Chinese Style Penhold Blade. Most short-pip attackers prefer a fast blade with a hard feel. These harder blades provide the speed and low ball throw that enable a short-pips hitter to hit effectively against heavy spin. I would suggest two blades for you to consider, the Yoshida Kaii and the Primorac Carbon CS. The Kail is a 7-ply all-wood blade which offers moderate speed and good control. The Primorac Carbon CS is the blade of choice for advanced short-pip attackers looking for maximum speed. Both of these blades have the playing characteristics your style requires. Your choice will be how fast a blade you feel you need.
Good Luck,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
Name: Matthew
Current Blade: Firehand
Current Forehand: Sriver 2.1mm
Current Backhand: Sriver 2.1mm
Question: "I want to change to a whole different racket and asking for your advice. I'm an all around attacker that likes to chop and do hook shots to throw my opponents off there game. I play close and mid distance. I would
like a lighter, faster blade with more dwell time. What do you suggest I choose?"
Answer: Hi Matthew,
Your Firehand Blade is quite fast and has a hard feel which produces a short dwell time. To increase the dwell time look for a blade marked with a medium feel. You can see a comparison of all our blades by speed, control, and feel located on our website. Just click on “blade specifications”. You might want to take a look at our new Photino Blade which is just a little faster than your Firehand but has a medium feel. The Photino features our new ZL fiber which also adds to the dwell time.
Good Luck,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
Name: Jonnathan
Current Blade: VSG 4000
Current Forehand: SpinSpiel Juic
Current Backhand: Juic 999 Elite
Question: "Recently, I got the VSG 4000 for better control and a bit more speed, but right now I'm not feeling to great with these 2 rubbers, I feel they get dusty too fast and are too slow, I'm a player that likes to backhand loop and forehand loop a lot, an offensive player, So I was wondering which rubbers I should upgrade to, I was getting some recommendations for Sriver, and Sonic, but I'm not really sure."
Answer: Hi Jonnathan,
Your current rubber choices are VERY grippy. These are not your best choices for looping. Any rubber in the Sriver family will give you a nice grip but not too much.
If you plan on re-looping a lot of incoming loops then I would strongly suggest you try some Bryce. It is truly fantastic for relooping topspin.
Best of luck, Mark Nordby |
Name: Michael
Current Blade: N/A
Current Forehand: N/A
Current Backhand: N/A
Question: "What role can a robot play in developing your game? Who should get a robot and why?"
Answer: Hi Michael,
As a coach, I use a robot a great deal in my coaching programs. It is a great tool but like all tools the better you learn to use the robot the more effective it is. Table tennis skills are developed through the use of a great many drills. Most players in the U.S. have limited access to training facilities and training partners. Often clubs are only open once or twice a week and many clubs do not have high level players to train with. In these cases a robot can really be a major help in developing your game. It is important that you consult a coach about the best drills for you to be using when working on a robot.
Best wishes,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
Name: Mark
Current Blade: Petr Korbel FL
Current Forehand: Bryce 2.1mm
Current Backhand: Speedy-P.O. 1.9mm
Question: "Hello, I have been playing Table Tennis casually for many years. I just got back into playing after about a year of not playing at all. I used to be an aggressor hence my choice in paddle and rubbers. Upon my return a few weeks back I have found that I am more of a looping defensive player now with strength to his back hand side (I tend to try and use that side strictly) and wanted to know if the rubbers I have now are fine or if I should find something else. Also, the Korbel paddle is meant for offense more so... so I was wondering what sort of paddle I should be looking for."
Answer: Hi Mark,
If you desire to play a more defensive topspin game then you will probably need to change your rubbers. You may want to try one of our Super Spin Rubbers such as Tackifire. It will offer you more control and spin for your looping game and you will still have plenty of power to finish the point. The Korbel is a very popular blade for almost any type of topspin game and should be fine for you. I would suggest changing your rubber first and then evaluating your blade choice at a later date.
Best wishes,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
Name: Sunil
Current Blade: Combi Flared Handle
Current Forehand: Sriver
Current Backhand: Sriver
Question: "I wish to change my racket - as this is an old racket. Which one should I buy.
Style of play:
- play at the club - not tournament play
Forehand:
- like to top spin a lot - and fairly aggressive play
- normally play close to the table
- like to play from the left corner of the table - to protect a weaker backhand
Backhand:
- fairly defensive - chops mainly
- a little looped top spin once in a while"
Answer: Hi Sunil,
To me this is part of what makes table tennis so cool ... the many choices available.
Now to your specific questions:
For medium speed blades I really like the Jonyer. For your FH rubber I would suggest you stay with the familiar Sriver you already use. It gets fun when we discuss your BH options. For regular play you should try Flextra 1.7. If you want to get adventurous, you should consider long pips or anti-spin. Now when you are just protecting your BH, you will still be making what your opponents see there much more confusing to deal with. This presents much more trouble for opponents when they do not get a normal weak play from your BH. If you decide to experiment some, you do want to get a bigger blade such as Defence II.
Best wishes, Mark Nordby |
Name: Andres
Current Blade: Zhang Yining
Current Forehand: Bryce Speed FX
Current Backhand: Bryce Speed FX
Question: "What is the difference between High Tune Rubber and the Bryce Speed rubbers?"
Answer: Hello Andres,
Butterfly’s Bryce High Tune Rubber is the second generation of a sponge technology that produces the same playing characteristics of freshly glued Bryce Rubber. If you are happy with how speed glued Bryce plays, then Bryce High Tune should work well for you.
Bryce Speed is actually a new product featuring the second generation of our High Tension Technology. Bryce speed offers even more speed and spin than does Bryce High Tune.
Best wishes,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
Name: Martin
Current Blade: Hao Shuai Champion Carbon
Current Forehand: Sriver G2 FX
Current Backhand: Solcion
Question: "Hi...I was using Water Chack, but it is not the same as the other glues, I feel my racket very slow and doesn´t sound. Basically is not the same... what kind of glue do you recommend me?"
Answer: Hello Martin,
Water Chack is a VOC free glue that has been developed to meet the new ITTF rules regarding glues. It is not speed glue and will not add speed or the sound you are use to hearing. My suggestion is to use the Butterfly Speed Optimizer to treat your rubbers before attaching them with the Water Chack.
Best wishes,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
Name: Kent
Current Blade: Preassembled Butterfly Senkoh S-100
Current Forehand: Butterfly Pan Asia
Current Backhand: Friendship 755 Long Pips
Question: "I am a chinese penholder. Twelve years ago, I was a promising youth playing competitively and was using Tackiness D and 755. I am planning to get back my game. My strengths are forehand spin and chop. Should I upgrade my blade?"
Answer: Hello Kent,
It sounds like you are using one of our recreational line of rackets. So I would suggest you upgrade to a blade from the pro-line catalog. There is a world of difference between recreational rackets and pro-line rackets. If you come from a competitive background in the sport you will tell the difference the first time you hit a ball with a top-line racket.
Best of luck,
Richard McAfee, USATT National Coach and Hall of Fame Member |
|